Monday, May 19, 2008

Heart of Darkness Post

The theme of restraint is the most prominent in the novel Heart of Darkness. Restraint was what saved Marlow while it was the cause of Kurtz failure.


Restraint is something that Marlow assumed everyone practiced. As he reached
Africa he found this not to be true. It seemed as if everything was meaningless. The only people who seemed to understand restraint were the manager and the cannibals. Marlow states, “The cannibals some of those ignorant millions, are almost totally characterized by restraint.” Even though they out numbered the whites, they did not attack them. Marlow later characterizes them stating, “…would have as soon expected restraint from a hyena prowling amongst the corpses of a battlefield.” Marlow is impressed by such restraint that the cannibals show compared to even Kurtz. Even though they outnumbered the whites, they did not try to harm them. Or at least the ones that were near the white’s camps. The cannibals that follow Kurtz also practiced restraint towards the whites. When Marlow was trying to rescue Kurtz the natives did not harm him when Kurtz told them not to. In the novel Marlow’s restraint seems to be work while the manager’s work is to keep up with his appearance. It is these restraints that allow them to not fall into the darkness of the Congo. He soon discovers that the only way for people to not lose themselves in the darkness is to find their own restraint. In the case of Kurtz, he practiced no restraint and got lost in the darkness of the Congo. For example he gave in to the temptations of power and suffered the consequences. Even though Kurtz used to be a man with morals much like Marlow, those are lost when he reverts back to his primitive nature in the heart of the Congo. Even at Kurtz’ lowest point he crawled back into the jungle because he had no restraint over the need to be with the natives. Although at Kurtz’ death scene he exhibits some restraint when he says, “The horror! The horror!”. Marlow takes this statement as Kurtz’ judgment on himself as well as a hint of a soul inside of Kurtz. Kurtz is not alone in his lack of restraint in most of the novel. The helmsman display a lack of restraint when they open the shutter of the cabin, as well as the pilgrims who eagerly shoot the harmless natives.

The theme of restraint in Heart of Darkness is seen throughout the novel. Whether it is the presence or lack of it is between each of the characters. There seems to be a direct relation between restraint and losing oneself within the darkness of the Congo. This is made explicit in the juxtaposition of Kurtz and Marlow.

1 comment:

Mr. J. Cook said...

Your essay discusses the theme of "restraint" by explaining why restraint matters and then providing examples of restraint and lack of restraint in the novel. The essay does all of this effectively.

However, the essay doesn't quite explore the theme itself. What exactly is restraint? What exactly are the characters like Marlowe restraining from? What is the darkness? And why is Kurtz indulging in the darkness? (Is indulgence the opposite of restraint?) Does the darkness lure us into it? Is it attractive? How? Why?

Then on another level is Marlowe right to restrain himself? Is Kurtz better off there in the darkness than in "civilization"? Are there hints that civilization is itself another darkness? (Look closely at the first several pages.) Therefore, is what we call civilization merely the illusion of restraint from embracing darkness?

Why do the natives appear restrained in the same setting in which Kurtz appears unrestrained (indulgent)? Is darkness relative? Is restraint relative? (In other words what in our culture looks like restraint might look like indulgence to an outsider...)

All of these questions occurred to me as I read the novel and occurred to me again as I read your essay.

Your essay finds a kind of answer--the book is about restraint: those who restrain, those who don't, and the consequences--but this apparent answer actually gives way to more questions worth exploring.

Grade: 6